That disillusionment and compromise are the only things brought by the changing times is an absolute, and at first glance excessively pessimistic, perception of the post-war era. However, when looking closely at the term “disillusionment” it could be considered in an independently positive light. It is possible that Larkin is not cynical in condemning the consumer society to unfulfilled lives, but was merely observing that people are capable of looking through the promises handed out by the world built on adverts that exploit their dreams and underlying hope for a more fulfilling future. It could even be said that by mentioning the compromise that has to be made, Larkin acknowledges the value of these dreams and the hopeful optimism that they can bring, without detracting from the vital role that their compensations play in achieving fulfillment in everyday life.
The use of metaphor within the poems “Here” and “Essential Beauty” is absolutely key to provoking a diverse range of interpretations and responses to aspects of the changing era.
The poem “Here” describes a journey from the English countryside to Hull, both literal and metaphorical as we see the change in view, and in the post-war society. This gives an ironic quality to the title “Here” as at no point is there ever a set place on a journey. It could be argued that this ever changing, ever moving pace through the era does not allow people to achieve set values, such as Larkin’s three grand illusions; happiness, fulfillment, and individuality.
The form of the poem is in four equal stanzas which is key to the movement as it suggests four equal, metaphorical stages. However, the poem is structured through one twenty-four line sentence that effectively separates the first three stanzas from the last. This two part structure allows the final three sentences and the triplet of “here” to be considered in its irony, as we understand that this end destination is something Larkin expects is largely beyond most of us.
In fact, this structure causes the poem to come full circle, reflecting the romantic ideals that are portrayed in stanza one. The rhyming scheme supports this idea of hopeful romantic yearning as the loose quatrains are difficult to pin down, reflecting the abstract and unattainable nature of our dreams. Instead, what is more tangible is the commercial compensation listed in stanza two and the compromise of disillusionment in stanza three; it could be argued that these are the things that Larkin expects us to come to realise. Metaphorically then, stanza three is the end of the poem, portraying the reality of everyday life as well as the disillusionment and compromise that Larkin considers is all we have to anticipate.
At the beginning of stanza two the metaphor takes us into the town to “everyday living”, and a vision of is undeniably a better way of life for ordinary people. The reader is shown the promise of the consumer society, translated into an unmistakeable reality.
Larkin’s diction is never coincidental, and the use of the word “surprise” proves the substantial contrast between Hull and the countryside. The use of the word is ironic, setting us up to be let down as we anticipate something positive. This is reflected in the way Larkin describes the domes; beautiful traditional architecture, followed immediately by “cranes”; modern and ugly, a symbol for the change that was occurring, namely the building and destruction of a certain way of living. The fact that these commercial “compensations” are in place of what was implied by the preceding beauty indicates that this promise has fallen short already.
The lists are a deliberate device used by Larkin, a very quantitative means of describing the very subjective and qualitative ideals of beauty and happiness. Lists also create a fast pace, with continual change, reflecting the promise after promise that try to mask the compromise that inevitably follows.
By compressing words with hyphens (“grain-scattered”, “barge-crowded”) Larkin does not show a full picture, suggesting an element of deception to the surroundings and the commercial promise, which stops it from being truly appealing. The continual use of alliteration also adds to the cluttered feel of the words, further reducing reader appeal. It could be construed that this is Larkin’s way of preparing the reader for the ugly truth, proving how technique can be used to change the readers perception of the era.
There are potential metaphors to be found in the “cheap suits” that are listed. More accessible due to their price, yet perhaps less worthwhile due to their quality, they can lend a different appearance to a man of any class, giving a facade of importance and authority as well as some form of identity. However, just because your appearance is transformed does not mean you will be any closer to fulfillment.
Is the word “cheap” a condescension that implies Larkin, with his privileged background, is distancing himself from the “cheap”ness and illusion it gives to the working class, thinking that they can better themselves without realizing the compensations they are making? Perhaps not as Larkin seems to show an “awareness of the continuation of human happiness” (Roddy Lumsden) that compensation can bring, and The Movement he was committed towards promised to “tell it the way it is”, which shows a commitment away from patronizing.
In a different light, the suits being cheap might not necessarily mean that they are inferior, merely more disposable, a possibility that may indicate why Larkin could be considered condescending towards them in a society that rewards the replaceability of objects.
Stanza three still looks at commercial Hull, focusing on the negative and broadening the aspect of commercialism. The words “cut-price”, “dwelling” and “half-built” bring a sense of anticipation brought about by the chase of something that is never quite within reach, very possibly because it doesn’t quite exist. The everyday world, according to Larkin, is never one hundred percent and “we are all doomed to incompletement” (Larkin). This view limits the amount of disdain that can be inferred from the poem as it is an understanding, not a condescension of the human condition. Furthermore, this incompleteness may not be the negative it appears to be. Although reinforced by the negative connotations that surround the term “doomed”, this statement can be seen in a positive light; if we are all incomplete then we all have something to strive for and we all can relate to each and every person that has ever wanted happiness.
The metaphor of the “grim head-scarved wive” really pinpoints the truth; for all its commercialism Hull is still dull and grim, only undeceived due to the passage of time. This way the reader is shown that “time disproves” the commercial promise, bringing disillusionment to us all.
Materialism brings no fulfillment. This is the reality of the situation Larkin depicts and metaphorical end, as stanza four goes on to show that we will always seek more. As a final stanza it implies that it is a destination, embodying the illusions of happiness, fulfillment and individuality, but we are immediately disappointed as everything is described as “out of reach” just like these ideals.
This brings a well rounded and complex end to the poem. However, it could still be argued that the metaphor continues. Stanza four is comparative with stanza one in that it returns to something more natural, suggesting that the cycle will repeat. The line “from rich industrial shadows” in stanza one could be inferred to mean that not only will it happen again but it has happened before, a conclusion that could show us constantly striving and failing to achieve HFI, continuously skirting around the idea of these abstract illusions that we created to define yet more abstract concepts.
An obviously satirical piece of writing in tone, the poem “Essential Beauty” describes a series of adverts typical of the 60‘s, the seductive quality of which was exaggerated by the previous austerity. If the poem is satirical then it seems safe to say the title is as well. Part of the irony in the title is Larkin’s consideration that these things are not essential, he presumably sees how they are essential to others, however, he doesn’t see the link between these things and fulfillment.
The poem is in the form of two, large, sixteen line stanzas. The size of the stanzas and the manner in which they are so packed with details suggests how overwhelming and appealing adverts can be. This is exaggerated in modern society with the prevalence of increasingly large TV screens, literally making the adverts larger than life. The sheer number and continuity of adverts in the poem seems to reflect our lives, dominated by adverts that are literally and metaphorically everywhere, both in the post-war era and present day.
Structurally the poem is more complex than just two stanzas. The use of enjambement joins the two into one continuous set of descriptions, suggesting that Larkin wanted to make clear that the adverts are the dominating feature. This could be taken further, hinting that adverts prevent us from attaining happiness, whether by distracting us from achieving it or constantly creating new goals and leaving the concept of fulfillment out of reach.
The alternative argument for the poem being structurally split in two could be that the first stanza is a description of the promises that are made and our hopeful romantic yearning for them. With the second stanza viewed as a reflection, a realization of the compromises that have to be made and the more pragmatic disillusionment that Larkin believes we will all experience. This physical separation of the poem reflects the metaphorical gulf between human expectation and the daunting reality.
The adverts that are described have been specifically chosen, but there is still more emphasis on some than others. The triplet of the deceptive words “cover”, “screen”, and “block” strengthens the interpretation that adverts hide the reality of life with the promise of more. The triplet could also ironically reflect Larkin’s three grand illusions. During the American depression slums were built behind billboards, this reinforces the metaphor that if you take away the promise of the consumer society, all that remains is disillusionment.
Those who are sympathetic to Larkin would argue that this cynicism is necessary as it is so easy to get carried away by the facade of commercial promise. Whereas, critics would argue it excessively cynical, the imagery of “graves” and “slums” too extreme, arguing that Larkin seems not to want to acknowledge the things that bettered life, such as the NHS and improving education.
The deliberate couplets are dominant within the regular rhyming scheme, drawing attention to particular adverts such as the “silver knife into golden butter” the rhyme of “gutter/butter” signifying this as important. The use of colour is at first glance no more than the obvious surface description, but the fact that this “silver” and “gold” is occurring “high above” the gutter, dirt and poor standard of living cannot be coincidental. In this light, perhaps the colours signify a richness that reflects the class system that was still active at the time, or perhaps it goes further; implying that the rich promises these billboards hold is high out of reach to everyone living a down-to-earth, ordinary life.
Larkin commits four lines and a couplet to the description of an Ovaltine advert, describing a stereotypically happy family. However, the addition of the “quarter profile cats” that are so particularly one-dimensional proves this stereotype to be unrealistic. The cats are quarter profile due to being seen on the TV, an invention disdained by Larkin due to its ability to make consumerism more seductive, bringing the illusion of advertising into your home, making you more likely to buy in to this false happiness.
The Ovaltine advert is quintessentially English, white, and middle-class as many adverts were, but this is not an accurate representation of the post-war period, and even further from the truth of today’s multi-cultural society. The fact that this advert does not accurately reflect a vast proportion of the population of England may effectively distance some readers from the text even as they yearn for what it represents, an effect that would be emphasized in present day, making the movement into disillusionment all the smoother and more inevitable.
The commercial promises invite the possibility of compromise on a new level. Instead of compromising on what people wanted for what was available, it was suddenly closer to the opposite. So much was available that you had to compromise and just get what you wanted. In this simple way the post-war era brought compromise. It then remains to be seen what you consider to be truly happy and fulfilled, it is widely known that people who have everything are often discontent whereas people who have very little can be incredibly fulfilled. This may be more to do with purpose and companionship than anything materialistic, after all, “of what use is happiness when it’s not shared?” (Reymond Amsalem, 2012). Furthermore, the pitfalls of compromise and compensation were already a default within the emerging society. They are the realistic and very useful outcome, for some indivisible with happiness itself, a contrast to the flawed, extravagant promises of immediate satisfaction that fail to take into account long term benefits and fulfillment.
In conclusion, Larkin raises very difficult questions that have no easy answer. However, I believe that the title claim is true but can be accepted in a positive light by looking at the true meaning of disillusionment.
2,290
No comments:
Post a Comment