It has been said that “Larkin persistently explores the gap between what he expects of love and what it provides” (Andrew Motion). His constant awareness of the disillusionment that awaits the inevitable let downs of the promises that fail to deliver fulfillment throughout our human existence, is key to the realization that failure to achieve happiness is at the forefront of Larkin’s mind. Such that it influences his poems both subconsciously and in a manner that can be determined by even a casual reader.
The use of metaphors in the poems “Wild Oats” and “Mr Bleaney” help to provide a range of interpretations for the texts, whilst revealing Larkin’s own personal fears that are represented, be it in matters of love, death or old age, with a clarity that impacts the reader, introducing the thought that these all-encompassing insecurities are part of the human condition and experienced by us all.
The poem “Wild Oats” describes the meeting of two girls, one of which the speaker went out with for seven years. However he experienced an unsuccessful end to what was more than just a casual relationship, we know this as he “Gave a ten-guinea ring” that was returned to him. It is clear that the speaker still has lingering thoughts about the other girl he met that day.
The title “Wild Oats” is a conventional metaphor but the phrase “sowing your wild oats” is at odds with the sexual attitudes of the 50’s when such open and free sexuality would have been highly frowned upon.
The use of diction, particularly the phrasing of “about” in the very first line suggests a casual approach that borders on flippant, it may also be a suggestion of denial. Precise use of the prosaic language “I could talk to” seems to be a message to the ordinary people that Larkin writes to, to stay down to earth, because it is better to stay grounded than to be disappointed.
There is a deep contrast between the description of the two girls, the use of “English rose” and “specs” as nouns is symptomatic of the gulf “between hopeful romantic yearning and disillusioned pragmatism” (Andrew Motion). Ruth Bowman, perviously in a relationship with Larkin, wore glasses which suggests the use of “specs” hints at his own insecurities in a hidden autobiographical manner. Perhaps “specs” is even a metaphor for the mediocrity we settle for.
The poem is set out in the form of three equal stanzas of eight lines, the use of enjambement linking the first two stanzas. The first two stanzas show the emotional response he had to the relationship and the end stopping that separates the third stanza reflects the separation that is described within it.
In terms of describing the relationship Larkin relies on numbers and the form of list. The man wrote 400 letters suggesting a level of commitment that contradicts the title and casual start to the poem, however, the numbers are deceiving and only superficially impressive, as 400 letters in 7 years is not that many. The speaker could be bemoaning the fact that even the effort put in to 400 letters did not lead to a successful relationship, the scorn and dismissal that is hinted at, reflecting Larkin’s own insecurity.
There is no formed poetic rhythm which lends to the down-to-earth feel of the language, however, the speaking voice gives some prosaic rhythm. There is also no formal rhyming scheme, the two deliberate rhymes “doubt/out” and “snaps/perhaps” draw the readers attention to the most important parts of the poem. They point to the gulf between, the compromise and the reality that the chasing of romantic ideals is the undoing of us all. This proves the poem is not just about Larkin, but about us all, and the universal unattainability that creates hope.
The speakers dialogue is all about the speaker, considering the ring “[he] got back” not her or her feelings, which is a very selfish and misogynistic approach. The phrasing of “unknown to the clergy” makes it clear that this relationship was not about marriage and the speaker does in fact go out of his way to distance himself from marriage. At this point it becomes increasingly clear that there is more, not less, of Larkin’s fears about love and relationships in his poems. Marriage and commitment was a large part of the social attitude of the time, much less apparent in the modern secular society, but Larkin himself never wanted to commit to marriage.
The phrase “useful to get that learnt” is deliberately colloquial, showing a dismissive attitude that hints at Larkin’s rejection of love and relationships, reinforcing that Larkin cannot help but represent his own views. The use of brackets in a poem is unusual and so highlights the words “so I thought”, imparting Larkin’s feelings quite consciously and showing how he has been hurt by rejection. The hesitancy shown by the speaker at this point is not towards the “English rose” but what she represents; happiness, fulfillment and individuality.
Another poem, Mr Bleaney, addresses the claim that there is nothing of Larkin in his poems. The poem describes the speaker visiting the deceased Mr Bleaney’s rooms. Spending his time thinking about Mr Bleaney’s life and what it must have been like. The poem is about old age and death, and the purposelessness of age seems to be looked at particularly, dominated by boring, time filling routines. It is very easy for a reader to reject this vision for themselves. However, age makes us more accepting even as time disproves. In essence, at the same time we grow to realize that we may never be fulfilled, we also accept that this may not stop us from being content. In this way Larkin shows that “His pessimism [is] always tempered by a strong awareness of the continuity of human happiness”(Roddy Lumsden).
In the second stanza we see what kind of lifestyle Mr Bleaney had. The seemingly unimportant details that vary from day to day such as “sauce to gravy” are what he looks forward to as it is the only exciting contrast left for him in his otherwise bleak surroundings. The life he led is also represented by the characteristic use of lists, making the room bare, with no colour or elaboration. It appears at first glance to be a list of the room’s features but could be construed as a creative metaphor for Bleaney’s life itself; empty.
The poem is in the form of seven, four-line stanzas with a regular rhyme scheme. The enjambement of stanzas splits the poem in two with the main description being followed by two stanzas of what could be called self-reflection. The poem takes the form of a regular rhyming scheme until the final stanza. The poem ends with the half-rhyme “nature/sure” suggesting that the monotony of old age is reflected in the regularity and is broken at the end due to an unwillingness to accept the vision of old age. The phrase “I lie where Mr Bleaney lay” is a creative metaphor of his understanding that this fate may become his own. Attention is further drawn to it due to the alliteration and internal half-rhyme, emphasizing the crucial importance of the moment; the action of reclining on the bed being the moment of transfer when he becomes Mr Bleaney in his imagination. The use of “lie” may be a pun on the meaning of the word as he is literally lying down but could also be lying to himself, like we all do about the inevitability of old age. “Lie” is also in the present tense, suggesting that for the rest of the poem, and his life, even stretched to the rest of human existence, this is the sole, bleak, and inexorable future. By switching from the third person singular “if he stood” to the third person plural “how we live” Larkin shows not just his own insecurities but fears that are shared at a universal scale, achieving empathy in a wider sense than that of his own revealed feelings.
Larkin had a paranoia of old age, loneliness, illness, and death that some could say was self fulfilling as he died sad and alone, much like Mr Bleaney. Therefore, there is arguably more of Larkin in Mr Bleaney than there is in Wild Oats. It has been said that “[Larkin’s] poems are infected with a sense of premature despair”(Margaret Drabble), but rather than spoiling the poem’s interest, it could be said that this gives emphasis to the points that Larkin seems to be trying his best to hammer home, that happiness is unattainable.
When the speaker says “I’ll take it.” he accepts the room, but it is so spartan that it seems an odd decision, so much so that it must reflect something else, it cannot just be a reference to the room. What he is really accepting is what comes with old age, the fate that Mr Bleaney succumbed to. The speech marks draw attention to this important moment that abruptly cuts off the listed description of the room, almost as if it is too painful to imagine as his own future. He accepts it because he is honest with himself and seems to realize there may be nothing better for him. It seems overwhelmingly so that there is more of Larkin in this poem than in Wild Oats.
The ending is deliberately offhand and unpoetic, which reflects the abrupt interruption of the previous list. It is as if any remaining hopefulness gives way as he dwells more on growing old. “I don’t know” is self consciously prosaic language and makes Larkin’s feelings being made perfectly clear by his upset rejection of this vision of old age.
The “one hired box” is a metaphor for death. Literal both in terms of a coffin and Mr Bleaney’s bare room, it could be suggested that these things are not separate. If there is in fact no difference between these places then those that reach old age without fulfillment could be seen as merely “unrested dead” with nothing more to gain.
In conclusion, I believe that Larkin’s approach to love, old age and death is honest, brutally showing the inevitability of rejection and death on both a personal and universal level. Larkin himself has written that he only thing to do with life is preserve it “by art if you're an artist” and so I feel the claim that there is nothing of him in his poems was only ever tongue in cheek and that writing held a cathartic value within the opportunity to express his hopes and fears. Andrew Motion said “His poems have an unmistakably affirmative aspect”, the insecurities exposed that were relevant to the audience at the time he was writing are still relevant today, and arguably relevant for many years in the future; for as long as we continue to thrive as a species experiencing love, growing, changing and dying then there is nothing more relevant or more comforting than sharing the hopes and fears that come with these occurrences and realizing the universality of their impact.
1,862
No comments:
Post a Comment